Reviews For Dear Nobody
You must login () to review.
Reviewer: Kendall15 Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-05-06 - 07:59 pm Title: Chapter 4

Another great chapter! It is so bad that Logan doesn't want anything to do with the baby and he chose to leave them, I am waiting for the next chapter. I'm happy Ororo stood strong for her child, she is the strong and peaceful goddess of course. I just hope everything goes smoothly for them, I can't wait to see if Logan comes back or not and see the baby. This is a wonderful story written with good interpretation on each of the character's emotions but written in a good poetic format, I'm lovin' this, keep it up girl!
-Kendall15


Author's Response: Are you sure Logan doesn't want anything to do with the baby?

Reviewer: lamisi Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-05-06 - 04:51 pm Title: Chapter 4

okay. . .this is getting more and more interesting. i admit that i was shocked at the tone of the first chapter and wasn't sure if i liked it or not. as you show ororo going through the emotions, however, you seem to have captured her humanity. nicely done.

as for this chapter. . . i wanted to slap the sh-t out of logan. must be good writing!

Author's Response: Thanks alot I'm glad you do like my story

Reviewer: Kendall15 Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-05-06 - 02:22 am Title: Chapter 3

Another great chapter, I'm lovin' this ficlet. Ororo changes even more in the third chapter and it's so sweet of her feelings now towards her baby. I'm hoping you can update soon, this is very good. Keep it up!


Author's Response: thnak you for your reviews, it's given me alot of support and reason to keep going with this fic.

Reviewer: OriginalCeenote Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-05-06 - 01:37 am Title: Chapter 3

Interesting "poetic prose" structure. Seeing a little more accountability, which is good. Need to tweak some spellings, wouldn't hurt to get a beta, but this is moving along a bit.

So, what's she going to do after she has the baby? Any thoughts?

Author's Response: No thoughts yet, and I'll think about getting a beta. Thanks

Reviewer: OriginalCeenote Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-05-06 - 01:34 am Title: Chapter 2

Okay. This turned the tide, a little. I love the graphic, by the way.

I'm wondering why the baby's name is still nobody, though, since she had assigned it enough personhood to apologize. Good to see she's motivated by a fear of ending up alone, but again, we don't have a clue quite yet of who left her alone. We assume it by what we know of her character's history as an orphan, granted, but...give us more. Good structure, nice prose, but sell me on this. I am off to read your next chapter.

Author's Response: Don't worry the baby will get named very shortly. i'm glad your still reading though.

Reviewer: Kendall15 Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-04-06 - 03:01 am Title: Chapter 2

This is a really good chapter, please continue on. Your writing style is good, and I love the pic. Please update soon

Author's Response: I'm glad your enjoying my story, I'll be updating very soon so keep reading, ;D

Reviewer: modernbard Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-02-06 - 09:51 pm Title: Chapter 1

Not what one would expect from Ororo. But then sometimes its the unexpected reactions that prove to be the truest ones. I must say I'm not sure I like the reaction, but I'll hold judgement until later. It might be warrented.

Author's Response: So far all my reviewers have said similar things to what your saying, and I understand where your coming from entirely. Again, thanks for the review much appreciated

Reviewer: just a reader Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-02-06 - 07:16 pm Title: Chapter 1

At first I thought it would suck, since it seemed out of character, but it's really well written and has me intrigued. I think future chapters will clear this one up.
But at least I want you to know that, unlike some of the writers who submit to this site, you actually do have talent.

Author's Response: Wow, thank you so much for this review, I'm glad you think i have some talent-I dont think I have any talent whatsoever. I know this story is out of character, but hopefully you being the reader will see some change in that aspect of the story-hopefully.

Reviewer: serial charmer Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-02-06 - 02:53 pm Title: Chapter 1

well, right now i'm a little uncomfortable about this. so far, we've been presented with an out-of-character ororo thinking some pretty awful things about her unborn child. i enjoy seeing a unique side of her, but it has to be believable; and right now, the believability's not there. if you want me (the reader in general) to sympathize or even remotely care about her situation, then i think you need to sell us on ro's position. convince us that THIS ro in THIS story would act this way.

other than that, i do like the structure of the chapter...

Author's Response: All I'm going to say since I keep repeating myself is things in this story do change.

Reviewer: OriginalCeenote Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-02-06 - 05:42 am Title: Chapter 1

I'm coming at reading this from the mom angle. When I see Ororo's thoughts here, they seem like very frightened, angry thoughts, and like she isn't accepting much accountability for how the baby got there. At least not yet.

When I read those thoughts, the liberal side of me says "Hm. Hate. Resentment. Won't love. Sounds like she is really talking to Logan for deserting her." I can't believe that she would feel that way about the baby him or herself. She's already admitted that she sees it as a life, not just a bunch of cells.

I won't rate this yet, but I won't discourage, either. Compelling back story and responsible coping from 'Ro in subsequent chapters might make this one seem less stark. My eye watered a little by the second paragraph, I won't explain why. Tragedy is supposed to add value to joy, not just be tragic in and of itself. Show us why she feels this way.

Author's Response: I'm glad your coming from the mom side of things, instead of the Ororo side of things as she sees everything as an equal. Usualy in stories that include Ororo and a child I find they always come from the nicer side of pregnancies, such as nice warm feelings you may encounter, I was trying to come from a different angle entirely, like shock. Further on in this story some chapters try and explain why she wrote what she did and so I hope you keep reading. Thank you for your review.

Reviewer: Kendall15 Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-02-06 - 12:51 am Title: Chapter 1

Wow, the first chapter interested me and it was pretty deep. I could feel Ororo's pain but still Ororo should know this is an innocent child who had nothing to do with her night of passion whit whoever. But I loved your first chapter and I am eager to read the next one, keep on writing please, I could tell this is going to be a good story.
-Kendall15

Author's Response: I hope you do keep reading and thank you for your review. Will be updating shortly.

Reviewer: Kathy Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-01-06 - 09:35 pm Title: Chapter 1

That was unexpected...but I'm curious to know what happened for her to not want the baby. I'm guessing rape. Rape victims often resent their child and I do not think that every single one of them that decides to keep it (to give up for adoption or whatever) grows to love the baby as months goes by. They may in fact hate it or feel nothing for the baby.

Author's Response: I can tell you now its not rape, I would never do a rape story. Keep reading to find out what happens though, I will be updating soon. Thanks for your comment, very much appreciated.

Reviewer: Sango Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-01-06 - 09:00 pm Title: Chapter 1

That is so tragic and depressing. But you got my interest. Is there more to come?.

Author's Response: Yes, there is more to come.

Reviewer: windrider1 Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 12-01-06 - 08:08 pm Title: Chapter 1

ok, seriously, that was horrible. Not the writing--in fact, I don't see a structural problem--the problem is the sentiment. First, Ororo would NEVER feel that way--hell she was impreganated by a brood alien for cryin' out loud, and debated nurturing it. Normally I never leave bad reviews, because all writers should be encouraged, but that was the most irresponsible piece of writing ever. No mother worth breathing would ever--EVER--have that mentality toward a child--even unplanned ones. To do so, is just sick.

Author's Response: I know its horrible in that sense but thats where I was coming from, I was looking at a different angle of how Ororo might feel if she'd only just found out, instead of having her all motherly. It will change in the next chapters I promise.

You must login () to review.